Saturday, June 20, 2009

Gnarly Head Old Vine Zin 2006 (GUEST REVIEW)

Thought I would treat you all to Tom's second guest review. He fits right in, don't you think? Enjoy!


Cheers,

Joy

----

Gnarly Head Old Vine Zin 2006

I hate plums. They are just about the only food that I actively avoid and generally refuse to eat. Admittedly, this has always proven to be a good thing, because no one in the world ever seems inclined to seriously insist that anyone eat anything flavored with plums. Oh, sure, some people eat plums, but no one seems to really like plums all that much. At best, they are innocuous. To me, they are disgusting.

Meanwhile, there is a universe of different foods and beverages out there, and I have few qualms with any of them. I’m not overly fond of cucumbers or cherry tomatoes or black olives, but I will eat them in salads or any time they are included in a recipe. Generally, I dislike any dessert that includes coconut, but I still have been known to eat things that contain coconuts. I eat all sorts of things that most people find disgusting, and I’ll try anything once. I even like the food in the middle school cafeteria where I work. Everyone else complains about the overcooked, brown, crusty pizza and the imitation pork product boneless rib barbecue sandwich, but I genuinely like the stuff. In short, I am not difficult to please.

But I hate plums, and this wine tastes like plums. Concentrated plums, even. It says on the bottle that it “yields concentrated fruit flavors characteristic of great Old Vine Zinfandel” and that these flavors include “rich dark berry flavors,” several nationalities of oak, licorice, pepper, vanilla, and plum.

Actually, given that description, choosing this particular wine was obviously a bad idea. How is that list even mildly appealing? It sounds like a recipe for an ipecac or some sort of violent medieval purgative. Oak, licorice, peppers, and plums?

So, in hindsight, I guess it’s probably a good thing that all I can taste is the plums.

Except that I hate plums.

3 out of 10

BJs, $8.99

5 comments:

  1. 3 out of 10? I'd probably agree with that. Is this a wine I'd buy again? NOT!! First sip or two were not bad but the wine quickly loses flavor and becomes very thin tasting -- not a good sign for a Zin. There is no big taste or intensity for this wine. Nice label though!
    Paid $7.99 at a local Smyrna GA wine shop.
    ReplyDelete
  2. Love the review. Unfortunately I also like this wine. I'm not ready to place it on the top shelf, but for $8-10 it's easy to open on a weeknight after work. Call my palate unsophisticated, uneducated, and I'll agree. But human taste buds are at least as varied as other human charactistics, so drink what tastes good to you. So don't buy based on a review or a score, but whenever possible taste it before you buy it.
    ReplyDelete
  3. I too liked this wine. Nothing pretentious. Delicious with good gossipy conversation. But I like plums. And the word gnarly.
    ReplyDelete
  4. Love this wine, even though I am mostly a Merlot drinker. Good taste from start to finish. I have thought it was like silk in a glass....I recommend this wine.

    Y.B.A. Ohio
    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree. This stinks. I didn't like it two years ago when I tried it the first time and age didn't help. I would agree with the review on plums, coconuts, and black olives too...although I hate coconuts and black olives way more than you do. I give the wine a 3/10, plums, 2/10, coconuts, 1/10 and black olives minus10/10. I hate black olives. If it helps, when offered foods I dislike I just claim I am allergic to them.
    ReplyDelete

Your comments are welcome provided they are clean. Guest reviews are welcome, e-mail for details.